Black Friday: 15% off selected products. Click here to get your discount

Sleep aids for kids, without melatonin

Nine things that help a child wind down at bedtime. None of them is something to swallow.

Last updated

What helps a child sleep without melatonin? Mostly things they do, hold or listen to: a bedtime routine in the same order every night, a screen-free audio player, steady background sound, a dim warm light and slow breathing. This list covers nine, and says who each one suits.

Search for a natural sleep aid for kids and you mostly find gummies and drops. Those are still something you give a child. This list is about the half hour before sleep and what goes into it.

It is written for children of roughly 5 to 12 who are tired but cannot settle. If bedtime has been a struggle for weeks, or your child snores or is exhausted during the day, talk to your pediatrician before you buy anything.

What to try

  1. A bedtime routine chart

    Children who negotiate every step, or stall at each one.

    Four or five steps in the same order every night: bath, pajamas, teeth, story, lights out. A chart on the wall makes the order the rule, so you stop being the one who says it. A home-made one works as well as a bought one.

  2. A screen-free audio player

    Children whose head is still busy when the light goes off.

    Players such as a Yoto or a Toniebox play stories and music from cards or figures, with no screen and nothing to scroll. One familiar, slow story works better than a new one. Set the sleep timer so it ends by itself.

  3. A white noise machine

    Light sleepers, and children who hear every door and every sibling.

    A steady sound covers the sudden ones. Keep it low and across the room, not next to the pillow.

  4. moonbuddyours

    Children who are told to breathe slowly and do not know how.

    A soft breathing buddy for ages 5 to 12. Its tummy rises and falls in the child’s hands, and they breathe along with it. One button, four rhythms, no screen and no app, and it stops by itself after six minutes.

  5. A dim, warm night light

    Children who do not like the dark, and parents who read in it.

    The big light goes off early and a small, warm one takes over, so the room already looks like night before anyone is asked to sleep. Choose one that dims or switches itself off.

  6. A book you read aloud, again

    Younger children, and any child who wants you to stay a little longer.

    The same few books on repeat are the point. A story they already know has no surprises left in it. Agree on the number of chapters before you start.

  7. A notebook for tomorrow

    Children who remember everything important at a quarter to nine.

    Five minutes before the routine starts, they write or draw what is on their mind, and the notebook stays outside the bedroom. It gives tomorrow’s thoughts somewhere to wait.

  8. A cuddly toy with one job

    Children who want a parent in the room until they are asleep.

    A toy that lives in the bed and only comes out at bedtime becomes part of the signal that the day is over. Let them choose it.

  9. Blackout curtains

    Summer evenings, streetlights, and children who are awake at five.

    It is hard to believe it is bedtime when the sun disagrees. Curtains or a stick-on blind change the room itself, which no routine can do.

What about melatonin?

Melatonin is a hormone, and in the United States it is sold as a dietary supplement. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine advises that “parents should talk to a health care professional before giving melatonin or any supplement to children”, and that “many sleep problems can be better managed with a change in schedules, habits, or behaviors rather than taking melatonin” (health advisory, September 2022).

Two findings explain the caution. Reports to US poison control centers of children swallowing melatonin rose from 8,337 in 2012 to 52,563 in 2021, an increase of 530% (CDC, 2022). And when researchers tested 25 melatonin gummies, 22 were inaccurately labeled: in those that contained melatonin, the amount ranged from 74% to 347% of what the label stated (JAMA, 2023).

None of this means melatonin is never right for a child. It means it is a decision to make with a pediatrician, and that habits and a routine come first.

Frequently asked questions

Start with the routine: the same steps in the same order every night. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says many sleep problems are better managed by changing schedules, habits or behaviors than by taking melatonin. Around the routine, an audio player suits a busy head, white noise suits a child who hears everything, a dim light suits a child who dislikes the dark, and slow breathing suits a child who cannot slow down.

There is no single best one, because children lie awake for different reasons. A busy head suits an audio player or a notebook. A child who stalls suits a routine chart. A child who reacts to every noise suits white noise. A child who cannot slow down suits something to breathe along with.

Ask a pediatrician before giving a child anything to swallow for sleep, including supplements sold as natural. Everything on this list is something a child does, holds or listens to instead.

Practice in the daytime, not at eight in the evening. Put a soft toy on their tummy and let it rise and fall slowly: in through the nose, and a slightly longer breath out. If counting does not work, give them something to breathe along with, such as a hand on the tummy, rainbow breathing or moonbuddy.

Moonbuddy is made for children aged 5 to 12. It has one button and four breathing rhythms, needs no app, and stops by itself after six minutes. For teenagers and adults there is moonbird.

If falling asleep has been hard for weeks, if your child snores loudly or seems to stop breathing in their sleep, or if they are exhausted during the day. Nothing on this list replaces that conversation.

Keep reading

We make moonbuddy, and it is on this list. Everything else here is something we do not sell and earn nothing from. The research behind slow breathing is on our science page.